It's not runny if it's refrigerated after opening. Even when cold, it's not too hard to spread on soft whole wheat bread.

I've been buying this stuff for years. When I couldn't drive the 6 hours to my nearest TJ's, I had to rely on Smuckers Natural PB. Blech! It had a horribly 'burnt' taste!!

I have such a long list for my next TJ's run!

We love TJ's Marsala Sauce. I follow the cooking suggestion on the back of the jar for a quick and delicious meal. The sauce is very flavorful... sort of 'lick the plate clean' good!!